This website uses cookies

Read our Privacy policy and Terms of use for more information.

Listen to this one instead. This article is also an episode of the Field Notes from RCS podcast: about thirty-five minutes, in Mike's voice, with why this test looks harder than it is, the equipment most techs already carry, and what a wet casing does to your readings. The episode page has the player, the show notes, and a full transcript.

Article 0079 — The Panhandle Eastern Casing Test: Same Reading, Different Answer

FIELD NOTES FROM RCS

Article 0079 — The Panhandle Eastern Casing Test: Same Reading, Different Answer

00:00
00:00

A while back our crew was running an interrupted close interval survey for an operator working through a direct assessment on a stretch of line with five cased crossings. The assessment plan wanted every casing called one of three ways: clear, electrolytic couple, or metallic short. And since a metallic short goes to the top of the list, we had to know for sure.

At each crossing we stopped at the vent, read the casing against the same reference cell we'd just used on the pipe, and compared. Four of the five looked the way you'd expect. Pipe around −1.05 to −1.10 V instant-off, casing between −0.60 and −0.75 V. Several hundred millivolts apart. Easy call.

The fifth one read −1.06 V instant-off on the pipe and −1.06 V instant-off on the casing.

That's the reading that gets a couple of techs talking. Maybe the casing is shorted. Maybe the annulus is full of water. Maybe somebody hung an anode on the casing years ago and it's holding the casing more negative than bare steel would read on its own. All three are reasonable, the assessment plan still wants a call, and a pair of matching potentials can't make it by themselves.

❝

Matching potentials tell you the casing needs a second test. They don't tell you what the answer is.

Here's how we sort it out.

Why Matching Readings Don't Settle It

A casing can sit in one of three conditions, and the potentials alone can't separate them.

Clear. The spacers and end seals are doing their job. The casing is bare steel at whatever potential, usually −0.5 to −0.7 V. The carrier pipe is coated and polarized where it's buried on both sides of the crossing, and that's what the test lead reads; inside a dry annulus it's sitting in air, with nothing to polarize. Read pipe and casing against one reference cell and they sit a few hundred millivolts apart, sometimes a volt or more.

Metallic short. Metal touches metal somewhere in the casing. A spacer failed, the pipe settled, a strap or a piece of debris bridged the gap. Electrically the two are one structure now, and they read the same. Worse, the CP current takes the metal path: it collects on the big bare casing, runs through the contact, and goes back to the rectifier. The pipe inside is shielded and gets almost nothing. And the casing itself is a large bare holiday on a system that was sized for a coated pipe. It soaks up current the pipe on either side was supposed to get, so potentials sag for some distance around the crossing, and a line that read fine last year can fall below criterion this year with nothing else changed. A low spot around a casing is often the first sign.

Electrolytic couple. Water or mud got past an end seal and filled the annulus. The casing picks up CP current on its outside, and some of it goes through the casing wall, through the water, and onto the pipe. The casing is working like a foreign structure under interference: picking up on the outside, discharging on the inside. The inside is the surface that corrodes. People call this an electrolytic short, but it isn't a short circuit. Holtsbaum's CP Survey Procedures calls it an electrolytic couple for exactly that reason. Current still reaches the pipe through a string of resistances.

The trouble is that potentials overlap across all three. A metallic short reads the same on both wires. A wet annulus pulls the casing more negative than bare steel ought to be, and so does a casing with old galvanic anodes on it. A poorly coated pipe in low-resistivity soil narrows the gap from the other direction. NACE SP0200-2023 puts the dividing line at about 100 mV: more than that and the casing is probably clear, 100 mV or less and you test again. It's a screening number, not a verdict.

And before any of this means anything, confirm what the wire is on. A test lead somebody labeled "casing" twenty years ago may be on the carrier pipe, on a foreign line, or on nothing at all. A broken lead floats, maybe 100 mV of nothing on the meter, and that number has been written down as the casing potential and the casing called clear, when a reading off the vent pipe would have shown it shorted. The vent is the casing. If the wire and the vent don't agree, the wire is the problem.

Carrier pipe entering the casing, with the vent and the test wires. The vent is the casing.

The Quick Checks First

Two tests are cheap, use what's already in the truck, and settle most casings.

Interrupt the rectifier and watch both. Put an interrupter on the nearest influencing rectifier, far enough away that the casing isn't sitting in the anode bed's gradient. Read ON and instant-off on the pipe and on the casing, reference cell in one spot. Then compare the shifts, not just the numbers.

  • Casing barely moves while the pipe swings: probably clear. SP0200 puts it at a casing shift under 10% of the pipe's shift, with the two more than 100 mV apart.

  • Casing moves the same direction and about the same amount, 75% of the pipe's shift or more: most likely shorted.

  • Casing moves the same direction but only part way: possibly an electrolytic couple.

The standard adds a caution worth repeating: with water or soil in the casing, this test may not be conclusive.

Measure the resistance between them. The four-pin soil resistivity meter in the truck does this. It puts out AC and nulls on a galvanometer, so the DC voltage between the pipe and the casing doesn't fool it the way it fools an ohmmeter, which is why you never use an ohmmeter for this. Hook the two current terminals to one wire on the pipe and one on the casing, the two potential terminals to a second wire on each, and read ohms. Four wires, two on each structure; with a single lead or the vent, you're reading the wire and the vent pipe along with the casing. SP0200 and the PHMSA guideline take 0.01 ohm or less as metal on metal. Above that, keep in mind the soil is a parallel path once the carrier pipe is tied in, so a clear casing reads a few ohms, not infinity, and anything in between is a reason to keep testing.

Holtsbaum's decision tree ends every branch the same way: confirm with at least two tests.

Back to the fifth casing. With the rectifier interrupted, the pipe swung from −1.55 V ON to −1.06 V instant-off, about half a volt. The casing went from −1.07 to −1.06. Ten millivolts. By the rectifier-cycling rule, that's a clear casing. By the instant-off numbers sitting on top of each other, it's a short.

Two readings, two stories. Time for the tiebreaker.

The Panhandle Eastern Test

The name comes from Panhandle Eastern Pipe Line, which worked out the method decades ago, and the AUCSC and PHMSA material still call it that. NACE SP0200-2023 lists the same test under a different name, the casing depolarization test, in its Appendix B.

The idea is simple. Turn the casing into an anode. Drain DC current off it toward a temporary ground (a cathode) and watch what the potentials do. A clear casing moves by itself. A shorted casing drags the pipe with it.

❝

Positive to the casing. You're making it corrode on purpose, for a few minutes, so it will tell you who it's connected to.

Setting Up

Positive to the casing, negative to a temporary ground off to the side. The reference cell goes over the pipe near the casing end and stays put.

1. Build the temporary ground. Drive a few ground rods off to the side of the crossing, 50 ft or so from both the pipe and the casing, not in line with either one. Wet the rods if the ground is dry. If you don't have rods, something metal that's already in the ground will do the job: a culvert, a run of guardrail posts, a line of fence T-posts. It has to be isolated from the pipe and the casing, far enough away, and not a foreign line or anybody's grounding system. It's the cathode in this circuit, so it won't corrode while you use it.

2. Wire the source. A variable DC supply, or a battery with a control resistor, with a shunt in series so you read the current as a millivolt drop (an ammeter does the same job if you carry one that covers the range), and a current interrupter in the circuit. A product we use often for this type of test is the Tinker & Rasor CS-10 portable current supply, which has a built-in interrupter and reads out its own output. Size the shunt for the current you expect; a yellow shunt covers most of this test's range, and the Wrong Shunt issue explains the two limits that decide it. Positive terminal to the casing. Negative terminal to the temporary ground. Check it twice. The polarity is backwards from every other CP hookup you make, and that's the point.

3. Place the reference cell. Over the carrier pipe, at grade, near the end of the casing. Not over the casing. Leave it in that one spot for the whole test, or mark the spot so it goes back to exactly the same place for every reading. The comparison only works if every number is taken against the same location.

4. Read the baseline. Pipe and casing, as found, before any current goes on. If the casing has CP or anodes on it, disconnect them if you can and let it depolarize first. Plenty of older casings have magnesium anodes connected directly to the casing, and those aren't coming off for a test. SP0200 says direct-connected anodes can negate the results, so note it on the sheet and put more weight on the other tests.

5. First increment. Set about 0.1 A and hold it a minute or two. Read the pipe and the casing with the current ON, then interrupt and read the instant-off on both. Record the current and all four numbers. With a second meter, add one more: pipe to casing direct, test lead to vent, ON and OFF.

6. Step up. About 0.2 A, then 0.3 A, same routine each time. Three steps is the minimum; a few more make the trend easier to see. Keep going until the casing has clearly moved, then stop. SP0200 puts the top of the range at 10 A, but you'll rarely need anywhere near it, and 10 A isn't a target.

7. Put it back. Current to zero, disconnect, recheck the as-found readings. While the test runs the casing is discharging current into the soil, which can show up as interference on anything else buried nearby. Take your readings and put it back.

Why both ON and instant-off. With the current on, the reference cell is sitting in the gradient of a casing that's discharging current, so every reading through it picks up the same offset. The pipe can look like it moved a few hundred millivolts positive when it didn't move at all. The offset is common to both readings and cancels when you compare them, which is why the older Panhandle Eastern procedure reads ON and gets away with it. Interrupt the current and the offset is gone; what's left is polarization, and that's what SP0200 says to judge on. The ON pair still earns its place, below. If you can't interrupt, the old procedure's fix was to read the pipe about 200 ft down the line, over the pipe, out of the casing's gradient.

Reading the Numbers

There are three signatures. Two of them are easy to see on the instant-off pair.

Clear casing. The casing shifts positive. Hundreds of millivolts, and it's not unusual for it to go right past zero and keep going. The pipe does almost nothing. It may drift a few millivolts more positive. Often it goes slightly more negative, because the pipe is the closest cathode to the current coming off the casing and picks some of it up. Either way, the gap opens step by step. Here is one of the four clear casings from the job.

Illustrative numbers from a clear casing. Instant-off readings, rounded.

Test current

Pipe (V CSE)

Casing (V CSE)

Difference

0 (as found)

−1.08

−0.66

0.42

0.25 A

−1.09

−0.55

0.54

0.5 A

−1.09

−0.42

0.67

1.0 A

−1.10

−0.19

0.91

Casing moved 470 mV. Pipe moved 20 mV, the other direction. Clear.

Metallic short. Both potentials go positive together, by about the same amount, step after step. The difference between them stays small and roughly constant, set by the resistance of the contact. That's one structure being depolarized, and the pipe inside it is not being protected.

Electrolytic couple. This is the one the test was never built to call. The PHMSA cased-pipe guideline says: the Panhandle Eastern method is not recommended for determining an electrolytic connection, and additional testing must be performed. A wet annulus with low enough resistance can drag the pipe partway along with the casing and look a lot like a short. It can also behave like a clear casing. It depends on how much water is in there and what's dissolved in it.

Put a number on it. The older Panhandle Eastern procedure goes one step past moves-alone or moves-together. Take how far the pipe shifted, subtract how far the casing shifted, and divide by the test current. With the potentials in volts, that's the resistance between carrier and casing in ohms. Above 0.080 ohm the casing is insulated. Below it, there is a low-resistance path between the two. PHMSA's cased-pipe guideline carries the same criterion. Run it on the ON pair or the direct pipe-to-casing reading, because a resistance only exists while current flows; at instant-off you're looking at polarization, not ohms. The clear casing above works out to about 0.5 ohm. The number has a limit, though: under 0.08 ohm says a path is there. It doesn't say whether the path is steel or water.

Here is the fifth casing from the job.

Illustrative numbers from the casing that read the same as the pipe. Instant-off readings, rounded.

Test current

Pipe (V CSE)

Casing (V CSE)

Difference

0 (as found)

−1.06

−1.06

0.00

0.25 A

−1.03

−1.02

0.01

0.5 A

−0.98

−0.97

0.01

1.0 A

−0.90

−0.88

0.02

1.5 A

−0.76

−0.73

0.03

They moved together. Three hundred millivolts on the casing, three hundred on the pipe, and the gap never opened past 30 mV. By the book, that's the shorted signature, and the ON readings agreed: about 0.02 ohm between them.

Left: a clear casing moves alone. Right: the fifth casing moved with the pipe.

Except the rectifier-cycling test an hour earlier said clear, and a bare casing resting at −1.06 V is more negative than bare steel has any business being on its own. SP0200 notes that a casing reading more negative than you'd expect for native steel may be an electrolytic path. Everything about this crossing fit a wet annulus better than a metal-to-metal contact. But "fit" isn't a result, and the test that would prove it isn't this one.

❝

When two tests disagree, you don't have an answer. You have a casing that stays on the list.

So that's how it was written up. Four casings confirmed clear, with the numbers to show it. One not confirmed, carried forward for a resistance test from both ends and a direct examination. Under the PHMSA guideline a metallic short is an immediate indication and an electrolytic contact is a scheduled one. An unresolved casing doesn't get to be either until somebody resolves it.

What Happens After the Call

A clear casing gets documented and goes back on the normal cycle. The regulations require electrical tests to confirm isolation is adequate but don't set an interval, so the interval is up to the operator (typically done with annual test station inspections).

A shorted casing has one best fix and two fallbacks. Clearing the short is always the best solution: excavate the ends, find the contact, clear it, recoat, and replace the seals and test leads. If it can't be cleared, add cathodic protection for the crossing, or fill the annulus through the vents with a wax or petrolatum casing filler so the pipe inside stops corroding whether the contact is there or not. Added CP doesn't rule out corrosion on pipe sitting in a wet annulus. A fill does. The fill is its own article.

Either way, the first question on a shorted casing is the one a coming issue in this series answers: where along the casing is the contact? There's a test for that too. It uses the casing's own resistance as a ruler, and it takes an afternoon, not an excavation.

Key Takeaways

  • Pipe and casing reading the same is a screening result, not a diagnosis. SP0200 draws the line at about 100 mV. Inside that, test again.

  • Three conditions, not two. Clear, metallic short, or electrolytic couple. An electrolytic couple still lets CP reach the pipe; a metallic short does not.

  • Run the cheap tests first. Confirm the wire (the vent is the casing), cycle the rectifier, measure the resistance with the four-pin box. Never use an ohmmeter between pipe and casing.

  • Panhandle Eastern: positive to the casing, negative to a temporary ground 50 ft off to the side, reference cell over the pipe and never moved. Three current steps minimum, ON and instant-off at each.

  • Clear casings move alone. Shorted casings move together. Judge it on the instant-off pair. Pipe shift minus casing shift, divided by the test current, is the resistance between them: over 0.08 ohm is insulated, under it is a low-resistance path, steel or water.

  • When two tests disagree, the casing is unresolved. It stays on the list until a resistance test or a dig settles it.

Referenced Standards & Technical Resources

  • NACE SP0200-2023 — Steel-Cased Pipeline Practices (Section 6, Monitoring; Appendix B, Monitoring Techniques B1, B2, B4 and B5; Appendix A, annulus fill)

  • PHMSA, Guidelines for Integrity Assessment of Cased Pipe, Rev. 1 (2010) — Exhibit C (casing-to-pipe tests), Table A.1 (the 0.080 ohm criterion), and the immediate / scheduled indication rules

  • 49 CFR 192.467 and 195.575 — electrical isolation

  • W. B. Holtsbaum, Cathodic Protection Survey Procedures, 3rd Edition — Chapter 10, "Road and Railroad Cased Crossings"

  • Peabody's Control of Pipeline Corrosion, 3rd Edition — Chapter 12, "Construction Practices"

  • J. L. Didas, "Evaluation of Pipeline Casing (sleeve) Testing Methods and What to do with a Shorted Casing," CEOCOR 2019

  • T. J. Barlo and A. Lopez, "Cased Crossing Methods," CORROSION/2000, paper no. 00726

  • AMPP/NACE CP 1 — Cathodic Protection Tester and CP 2 — Cathodic Protection Technician (course manuals)

  • AUCSC Intermediate Course (2025), Chapter 9 (cased crossings)

Roberts Corrosion Services, LLC

Established in 2011, Roberts Corrosion Services, LLC delivers comprehensive, turn-key cathodic protection and corrosion control solutions nationwide. Our end-to-end expertise encompasses design and inspection, installation and repair, surveys and remedial work. We provide drilling services for deep anode installations and a full laboratory for analysis of samples and corrosion coupons, as well as custom CP Rectifier manufacturing.

While our initial focus was on the Appalachian Basin area, we complete field work all over the US. We are a licensed contractor in many states and can complete a wide range of services.

Our biggest strength is in our flexibility for our clients. Solutions and Results.

Let us know how we can help.

Location: 39.251882, -81.047440

(304) 869-4007