In the field of corrosion control, "resistance to earth" is a key metric for evaluating the integrity of buried metallic structures like pipelines and tanks. For corrosion field technicians, this parameter goes beyond a simple electrical reading, it offers direct insights into coating conditions, cathodic protection (CP) effectiveness, and potential vulnerabilities that could lead to corrosion failures. By quantifying how current flows from the structure into the surrounding soil, resistance to earth helps inform decisions on maintenance, repairs, and system upgrades, ultimately supporting the longevity of the structure.

Understanding resistance to earth is particularly valuable in cathodic protection contexts, where it ties into potential surveys and current demand calculations. Whether you're conducting routine assessments or just troubleshooting, knowing this concept equips you to identify issues, refine protection strategies, and ensure compliance with regulatory requirements for corrosion control.

Resistance to earth, also known as structure-to-earth resistance, measures the opposition to electrical current flowing from a buried metallic structure into the soil. Expressed in ohms (Ω), it indicates the ease or difficulty of current dissipation through the earth. Factors influencing this resistance include soil resistivity, coating quality, exposed metal surface area, and environmental variables like moisture levels.

Soil resistivity, measured in ohm-centimeters (Ω·cm), is a primary driver. Low resistivity soils (under 3,000 Ω·cm in clay heavy or wet areas) allow easier current flow, which can highlight coating defects if resistance is unexpectedly low. High resistivity soils (over 20,000 Ω·cm in dry, sandy terrains) naturally increase resistance, potentially requiring higher CP currents to achieve protective potentials. Technicians often use tools like the Wenner four-pin method to measure soil resistivity, providing context for resistance interpretations.

In CP systems, resistance to earth aligns with Ohm's Law: R = V / I. High values suggest effective isolation, often from intact coatings that limit bare metal contact with soil. Low values indicate possible issues, such as coating holidays or unintended grounds.

This metric differs from "anode-to-earth resistance," which specifically measures the resistance between the CP system's anode (a sacrificial magnesium anode or an impressed current anode or anode bed) and the earth / electrolyte. That value is used to evaluate the anode's performance. Which is essentially how easily it can deliver protective current to the structure. Lower anode-to-earth resistance is typically better for efficient current output, but it depends on factors like anode material, size, placement, and soil resistivity.

The distinction is important because:

While they're related (both influence overall CP circuit resistance and current distribution), they're not interchangeable. Monitoring and optimizing both ensures a balanced and effective cathodic protection design.

Multiple elements affect resistance readings, and recognizing them ensures reliable data. Coating integrity is central: High-quality coatings like fusion bonded epoxy (FBE) can have resistances in the hundreds or thousands of ohms, minimizing CP current needs. Degradation from age, damage, or poor application reduces this, exposing more surface area and lowering resistance.

Soil properties vary by location and season. Moisture fluctuations can alter resistivity significantly, impacting measurements. Structure design matters too; extensive pipelines may show attenuation effects, where resistance varies along the length, requiring segmented evaluations.

External factors, such as stray currents from nearby infrastructure, can artificially lower measured resistance. During surveys, technicians should monitor for these interferences and use techniques like current interruption to isolate true structure-to-soil interactions.

Accurate resistance to earth measurements demand precise equipment and methodology to support informed CP adjustments. Two primary approaches include direct current injection and current interruption during potential surveys, each suited to different field scenarios.

When CP current sources can be interrupted, this method calculates resistance to earth while providing historical data on system changes.

This approach integrates seamlessly with pipe-to-soil potential surveys, offering dual benefits for CP verification and resistance assessment under AMPP guidelines and standards.

Results must be analyzed in context to help guide actions. High resistance (100 - 1,000 Ω or more) points to strong coating performance and minimal exposure, ideal for efficient CP. Low resistance (1 - 10 Ω) indicates possible defects like holidays or high conductivity soils, prompting further surveys such as direct current voltage gradient (DCVG) to evaluate.

Intermediate values (10-100 Ω) require correlation with soil resistivity and CP potentials. Track trends: Declining resistance over surveys indicates progressive issues.

For coated structures, resistance to earth data enables calculation of effective coating resistance, a valuable metric for monitoring coating quality over time. This views the structure as parallel resistances across its surface, normalized per square foot.

The average coating resistance (Rc) is calculated as: Rc = R × Surface Area of the Structure (in ohm-ft²).

Good coatings typically achieve 300,000 ohm-ft² or higher post-installation, reflecting quality construction. Acceptable values vary by factors like soil resistivity: lower in 1,000 Ω·cm soils versus higher in 10,000 Ω·cm environments. Experience and judgment determine thresholds, as no universal standard applies.

Collect data during resistance measurements, especially on new or recoated lines, to establish baselines. This aids in detecting degradation, informing recoating schedules, and optimizing CP designs.

Resistance to earth directly informs CP current demands, helping technicians estimate adjustments for unprotected or underprotected structures.

Use the formula: I_required = ΔV_required / R, where ΔV_required is the desired potential shift (ex, to -0.85 V).

Consider a rectifier outputting 3 A. Interrupted potentials: -0.82 V ON, -0.65 V OFF. Goal: Shift ON to -0.85 V (ΔV_required = 0.03 V).

Resistance to earth supports multiple CP facets. In coating evaluations, it identifies defect-prone areas for targeted repairs, integrating with techniques like alternating current voltage gradient (ACVG).

A 5-mile coated pipeline showed inconsistent CP potentials. Interruption yielded -0.75 V ON, -0.60 V OFF at 2 A output. ΔV = 0.15 V, R = 0.075 Ω.

Rc = 0.075 Ω × (pipeline surface area, ex, 100,000 ft²) = 7,500 ohm-ft²—below typical thresholds, indicating defects.

Soil resistivity (5,000 Ω·cm) suggested moderate influence. Follow-up DCVG pinpointed holidays; repairs boosted R to 0.5 Ω and Rc to 50,000 ohm-ft², restoring -850 mV potentials.

This demonstrates resistance data's role in diagnostics and resolutions.

Resistance to earth provides a foundational view of structure-soil dynamics, essential for CP optimization and corrosion mitigation. High values affirm protection; low ones signal investigations. Incorporate coating resistance calculations into surveys for comprehensive assessments, enhancing asset reliability.

Established in 2011, Roberts Corrosion Services, LLC delivers comprehensive, turn-key cathodic protection and corrosion control solutions nationwide. Our end-to-end expertise encompasses design and inspection, installation and repair, surveys and remedial work. We provide drilling services for deep anode installations and a full laboratory for analysis of samples and corrosion coupons, as well as custom CP Rectifier manufacturing.

While our initial focus was on the Appalachian Basin area, we complete field work all over the US. We are a licensed contractor in many states and can complete a wide range of services.

Our biggest strength is in our flexibility for our clients. Solutions and Results.

Let us know how we can help.

Website

LinkedIn

Location: 39.251882, -81.047440

(304) 869-4007