Transcript 0:00 [upbeat music] This is Mike Roberts with Roberts Corrosion Services, and this is the episode to discuss Article sixty-nine, CP Shielding: When the Coating Protects the Corrosion. 0:15 This one's about the shielding effect a coating or other things can have on the steel, shielding it from cathodic protection and from the surveys we use to check on it. The article opens with getting called out to a dig. 0:30 A lot of times this is exactly how it happens, and it's very close to the way it happened to me several times over back when I was a corrosion technician working for an operator. 0:40 And now that I'm a contractor, I still do a lot of this kind of work. Sometimes we're even the ones doing the digging. 0:48 Sometimes another company is crossing your pipeline, so you get called out to inspect your line and probably add a test station at the crossing. That's very typical for a corrosion technician. 1:00 You go out to the excavation. Obviously it's somebody else's project, but they've exposed your pipeline. 1:08 So you climb down into the open ditch, connect test leads to both lines so the crossing can be monitored later, and set a couple of magnesium anodes on your line in case you ever need to drain interference down the road. 1:20 Nobody called you because something's wrong. The pipe isn't backfilled and the connections are brand-new, so there's nothing to read yet. This part of the visit is visual. 1:30 It's the condition assessment of the exposed pipe that a crossing like this usually requires. Nothing about the segment says there's a problem either. 1:40 A nearby test station read fine at the last annual, and the last close interval survey over this spot was clean. Going in, you'd have called the coating here good. The coating is polyethylene tape. 1:53 At a glance it still looks intact. Then you notice a wrinkle, a spot where the tape has lifted off the steel. You press on it and water weeps out from underneath. 2:04 You peel back a corner and the steel under it isn't bright, and it isn't just discolored. It's pitted and actively corroding under a coating that never showed a holiday to any survey that passed over it. 2:16 Sometimes it's at a weld. Some pipelines have some sort of tape coat at the welds. You peel back that tape coat, and there's all kinds of corrosion underneath. 2:26 We've got a couple of good pictures of that in the article from a dig we did ourselves. 2:30 You can see what the corrosion looks like under that disbonded coating, and you can even see the yellow jacket right there beside it. 2:37 You take a step back and think, "Well, I've been measuring pipe-to-soil potentials here for years, and they always looked fine. They always show protected. We have excellent CP systems on this line. 2:50 We've done DCVG surveys before and there were no anomalies staked here, no defects that needed to be dug up and looked at. Why am I just now finding this?" 3:00 The readings said protected, the steel says otherwise, and both are telling the truth. This episode is about how that happens and what it costs you to misread it. 3:13 So you pull your records and look at the previous readings. 3:18 At the nearby test station, the last annual had the on potential at negative one point eight two volts copper sulfate, and the instant off at nine fifty millivolts. More negative than eight fifty, so it passes. 3:32 The station was half a mile back, so you pulled a close-interval survey for this exact spot, and its off trace runs right around nine fifty through here too. Two independent reads, same answer. Protected. 3:47 Neither off potential was inflated and neither one was a measurement error. Both were clean, defensible, passing readings, and the steel a few inches away was losing metal. Here's why that can be true. 4:01 Every potential you read, on or off, describes the steel that's electrically in contact with the soil and trading current with it, the bare metal at holidays, the surface your CP actually reaches. 4:14 Your reference cell reads the potential field that reachable steel produces. The steel sealed under a sheet of intact disbonded tape is screened out of that circuit. 4:25 It adds almost nothing to the field, so it barely shows up in your readings. A passing off potential describes the steel cathodic protection can reach. It says nothing about the steel hiding behind the shield. 4:38 The off potential is the truth about the steel your current can touch. The steel that's corroding is the steel it can't touch. So is there ever a time the readings passed and we still found disbonded coating? Yes. 4:52 Unfortunately, that's how it happens a lot of the time because above-grade surveys, like a close-interval survey or a DCVG, have a really hard time seeing disbonded coating. 5:03 A lot of times, maybe even half the time, when we find disbonded coating, we were digging for a different reason. 5:10 It had disbonded in a way that kept the steel from touching the electrolyte, so it wasn't receiving cathodic protection and there was nothing for a survey to pick up. Other times something did show up in a survey. 5:22 Many times somewhere in that disbonded area some of the coating eventually breaks apart and the steel makes contact with the soil. That's when you can actually see it, if it's big enough. 5:33 A small area, like at a weld, may not have enough steel in contact with the soil for your reference cell to pick it up, so that's very easy to miss. 5:42 And by the time it does show up it's already been corroding, so the readings are bad. You go out to dig it up and look at it, and you find all kinds of disbonded coating. 5:52 The way we'd explain that to a client, if it's still a CP shielding effect, the above-grade surveys can't show it. We're just happy to find it in a dig. Well, I guess happy is a relative term [chuckles]. 6:05 We're happy to find it so we can resolve it Nobody's happy to see disbonded coating, so it depends on your point of view. Start with what a good pipeline coating is electrically. It's a dielectric, an insulator. 6:20 That's the entire point. A sound coating blocks current from passing through it, so cathodic protection ignores the coated steel and concentrates on the few bare spots, the holidays, where it's actually needed. 6:34 The better the coating insulates, the less CP current is required and the longer the system lasts. Dielectric strength is a good thing to have. Now disbond that coating without breaking it. 6:48 Polyethylene tape is the textbook case, and it's no accident this happened on tape. Tape systems have wrestled with the same failure since they went in the ground. Water migrating under the tape during service, 7:02 soil stress dragging at the wrap as the ground swells and shifts, marginal adhesion from the day it was applied. 7:10 The coatings industry spent decades engineering around it because tape's known weakness is losing its grip on the steel while staying otherwise intact. 7:20 When that happens, the tape lifts into a tent or a wrinkle and a thin gap opens between the coating and the pipe. Groundwater finds the gap. Now you have an electrolyte-filled crevice with a roof over it, 7:34 and that roof is still a dielectric. The same insulating quality that made the coating good is now working against you. 7:43 It blocks CP current from reaching the steel underneath just as well as it once kept current off the steel it was bonded to. Except now there's bare steel under there, wet, with nothing protecting it. 7:56 The coating has stopped being a barrier that helps and become a shield that hurts. The dielectric strength that makes a coating good is the same property that makes a disbonded one dangerous. 8:09 This failure mode has a name. SP-0169, the same standard behind the eight-fifty criterion, calls it cathodic shielding, and it defines it. 8:20 Disbonded coatings can prevent CP current from reaching the pipe, leading to undetected corrosion. And the standard doesn't put the fix on the rectifier. It puts it on the coating. 8:32 Select coatings that resist disbondment and hold the line on application and repair quality. Inside that crevice, the chemistry goes right where we covered it in Article sixty-eight, the one right before this one. 8:45 Oxidation does not mean oxygen. The oxygen dissolved in that trapped water gets used up and nothing replaces it. But the absence of oxygen doesn't stop the corrosion cell. 8:57 The iron still gives up two electrons and leaves as an iron ion. The water just sits there and the chemistry and the pH drift. 9:05 And oxygen-starved ground is exactly where sulfate-reducing bacteria can set up shop and speed up the attack. 9:13 The crevice does everything an aggressive corrosion site does, and the one thing that's supposed to stop it, the cathodic protection, can't reach it. A quick word on cathodic disbondment. 9:24 It does belong on the list of causes, but it's easy to give it too much weight. 9:29 At a true holiday, the cathodic reaction creates a strongly alkaline, hydrogen-rich environment that can creep under the coating edge and peel it back. 9:38 That's cathodic disbondment, and good coatings are tested for their resistance to it. Excessive CP can make it worse. That does happen, say, when a system's being commissioned and some areas end up reading too high. 9:51 But on tape, disbondment in the ground is usually mechanical. Water and soil stress, not the current. 9:59 Disbonded coating that causes shielding or anything else in the hole that's causing shielding is very, very difficult to detect from the surface. 10:08 And that ties into how most of your above-grade surveys fundamentally work. 10:13 If I'm measuring test station potentials or doing a DCVG survey or anything like that, they all rely on the steel being able to make contact with the electrolyte. 10:25 If the steel can't contact the electrolyte, if you have some sort of shielding effect there, that DCVG survey is not going to measure current coming to or away from the pipeline. 10:35 And your pipe-to-soil potentials aren't going to be a true representation of what's going on right there because you can't see that steel. 10:43 It's not in contact with the same electrolyte you're placing your reference cell in. ACVG has the same blind spot. At a disbonded but unbroken coating, no current is leaving the pipe, so there's no gradient to detect. 10:59 Both coating surveys hunt for current crossing the coating, and at a shielded spot, that current isn't crossing. The survey walks right over active corrosion and logs nothing. And you know what? 11:12 We've actually had two issues on the differences between ACVG and DCVG, and they're both in the archive. Both titles start with ACVG versus DCVG, so they're easy to find. 11:24 They've been some of our more popular ones, and they're worth taking a peek at. The coupon won't save you either. 11:32 A coupon is a coating holiday you build on purpose, a known piece of bare steel taking on CP current the way a real holiday would. That's exactly why it's blind here. 11:43 The coupon is bare, CP reaches it, and it reads protected. It models the holidays, which are fine. It can't model the shielded steel, which isn't. 11:54 Your coupon hands you a clean instant off while the corrosion runs untouched a few feet away. Even your close interval survey, the over-the-line workhorse, reads the polarized potential of the steel CP can reach. 12:09 The shielded steel doesn't show up at the surface any more than it did at the test station. And here's the worst tell of all. A disbonded but intact tape coating keeps the line's current demand deceptively low. 12:23 The pipe still looks well-coated to your rectifier because electrically, it still is. The current just can't get to the steel that needs it. 12:32 Low, stable current demand on an old tape-coated line is not proof of a healthy line. It can be the sign of a line quietly corroding under its own coating. Every routine tool looks for current crossing the coating. 12:47 A disbonded coating that's still in one piece is still doing its job, keeping current from crossing. The article does a really good job of explaining why above-grade surveys don't always see it. 13:00 It is very difficult to see. 13:03 The best way to actually see it is a direct examination, which is another reason why anytime your pipeline's being exposed for any reason, you should always try to be there to examine the steel. 13:15 And if you find a hole where you have some disbonded coating at some welds, that's good to know because it could also exist elsewhere on the system. So what works? Three things in rough order of certainty. 13:29 Direct examination is the ground truth. Every bell hole is a free coating inspection. Integrity digs, tie-ins, foreign line crossings like this one. When the pipe is exposed, get your hands on the coating. 13:45 Don't trust tape that looks intact. Push on it. Feel for tenting and wrinkles. Look for water tracking and soft spots. The disbondment you can find with a gloved hand is one your survey already missed. 13:59 Inline inspection doesn't care why the steel is thinning. Magnetic flux leakage and ultrasonic tools measure metal loss directly, shielded or not. 14:10 On a tape-coated line with a disbondment history, ILI is often the only practical way to find shielded corrosion across miles of pipe you'll never dig. 14:20 If the line is piggable, the integrity program and the corrosion program need to be reading each other's data and document more than just the number. 14:29 Anytime you get an opportunity to see your pipeline exposed, that's where you can collect great data. 14:35 You should always try to collect lots of data because even if your pipeline's in great shape, that's good data to have. What type of coating it is, tape coat or epoxy? What kind of condition it's in? 14:48 What it looked like when you found it? What the soil conditions were like? Did it have anything on it? Was there rock shield? You can answer all those things when they expose your pipeline. 14:59 A lot of times while you're down in the hole and your job is to attach test station leads so that crossing can be monitored. Shielding corrosion isn't random. It tracks coating type, age, and ground conditions. 15:12 So what turns up in one bell hole tells you something about every similar foot of line. That's what makes the hole worth more than the potential reading you came for. 15:22 Whether that tape was a surprise or something you already knew was out there, it's a data point either way, and it only pays off if it's well-documented. Do that across enough digs and the picture fills in. 15:34 One accidental find at a crossing becomes a map of where to look on purpose. When a reading looks low, the first thing most of us do is turn the rectifier up. 15:46 That's something every corrosion technician does, and lots of times it's the right call. 15:51 But if you've got an area you know from previous digs or previous documentation is susceptible to disbonded coating, we really need to check some things out before we put too much protection on that line. 16:04 Cathodic protection suppresses corrosion by supplying electrons from outside, so the steel never has to give up its own. That only works where the current arrives. 16:15 Behind a disbonded dielectric coating, there's no low resistance path for current to arrive. That's what shielding is. 16:24 Turn the output up and you raise the potential on the steel CP can already reach, pushing that surface toward real overprotection, while the shielded steel sits right where it was, at its own freely corroding potential, losing metal at its own pace. 16:39 Next to none of that current ever reaches the face that's actually corroding. So if the CP can't reach the steel surface, turning up the CP isn't going to help. The fix is getting to that steel and repairing the coating. 16:55 Once you find it through direct examination, the best thing you can do is remove all the coating that's disbonded and any coating that's damaged. Get everything back to bare steel. 17:06 Get the surface prepped correctly, whether that's sandblasting or whatever needs to be done, and then put a good quality coating back over top of it. Basically, repair any area you find in a dig. 17:19 That's really the best thing to do about it. Then document it and continue to monitor it. A few details on each of those. 17:29 Disbondment runs under coating that still looks attached, so don't repair only the spot you can see. Probe outward and remove every bit that isn't tightly bonded back to where the adhesion is good. 17:43 Overcoating poorly adhered coating just carries the failure along under your new material. If the bond beyond the defect is marginal, it all comes off. And get all of that found before you start your repairs. 17:58 The repair is pretty invasive. You wanna do all of your sandblasting in one step, then move in with your coating. You don't wanna get all that done and then find out you have to keep going. 18:10 Assess the steel before you recoat it. Clean the corroded area, measure pit depth and remaining wall thickness, and document it. 18:19 If the metal loss is significant, that's an integrity question, not a coating one, and how to remediate it belongs to the integrity engineer and the operator's procedures, up to and including a cutout. 18:31 Either way, it outranks the coating repair. Don't bury a problem you haven't measured. Then the repair itself. Your surface prep has to meet whatever that coating calls for. Sometimes that's a near-white blast. 18:47 Sometimes it's hand tool cleaning. It depends on the coating. Anytime you're repairing coating in a ditch, you need to use a coating that's approved by the operator. 18:58 They have a list of approved coatings they've researched, they understand, and they believe are good for their system. The people installing it have to be qualified to do it. 19:08 And it needs to be compatible with the existing coating because you have to tie the two together. Where the list gives you a choice, lean toward one that bonds well and won't shield the steel if it ever lets go. 19:20 Sometimes they're not compatible, so do some research ahead of time. If you know what type of coating's in the hole, what can you use that's compatible with it? Sometimes that takes more than one coating. 19:31 We've seen situations where you're tying a newer epoxy into an older coal tar coating, and some operators will want a hot wax as a tie coat in between to cover the interface between the two. 19:42 So what really matters is good surface prep, the right coating for the situation, and making sure it's compatible with whatever the rest of the pipeline is coated with. 19:51 Then make your tie-ins and tapers into the parent coating, follow whatever your company's procedures call for, and holiday detect the repair before it's backfilled. 20:01 We were fortunate to get a look at the pipe at that crossing because of somebody else's project. Now there's another data point on that line and it's well-documented. 20:09 The disbonded coating that was found, the repair that was made, and how all of it went. It's one more piece of information to help monitor the system. 20:18 The biggest thing I'd add to this article, something that maybe isn't as much in the article, is this. 20:25 Disbonded coating and shielding effects are a primary reason you should always want to look at your pipeline anytime it's being exposed, for any reason. 20:34 Whether they're digging it up to install a valve, or because someone's crossing it, or because of some sort of encroachment, or because something else is being installed, you should always want to get involved. 20:46 Even if it's a project that doesn't involve corrosion at all, as a corrosion technician, you should want to go take a look at it. 20:53 If there are shielding effects, it's something that can be catastrophic because it goes unnoticed for so many years. It's not easily recognizable through above-grade surveys. 21:04 It usually comes down to a direct examination to actually catch something like this. And what I'd want a tech to take away from this one is knowing your system better and knowing what to look for. 21:16 If I'm working on a couple of pipelines and one has FBE coating with liquid epoxy on the welds and the other has yellow jacket coating with some kind of older tape coat on the welds, I'm looking for two different things when those lines are excavated. 21:30 On the FBE line, we're looking for backfill damage, breaks in the coating, things we can repair. On the tape coat line, problems aren't always as obvious because yellow jacket and tape coat can look completely intact. 21:44 In those situations, I might be more apt to remove some of the tape coat just to make sure there's no disbonded coating underneath. 21:51 I'd want to be prepared to replace or repair that coating because I might remove it and find no disbondment or corrosion at all. That's good. That's a good data point to record. But I'm looking for different things. 22:05 So understand the types of coatings you have. Which ones are more susceptible to disbondment and CP shielding and which ones aren't? Because it changes your approach and what you look for in a dig. 22:17 The full write-up is on the newsletter site. Field Notes from RCS, Article 69, CP Shielding, When the Coating Protects the Corrosion. One more thing before I let you go. 22:29 Subscribers can comment right there on the article page as long as you're logged in. We read every one of them. 22:35 So if this one raised a question for you or you've got something to add or you think we missed something, put it in the comments. 22:44 Until next time, this is Mike Roberts with Roberts Corrosion Services, and we'll see you on the next one. [outro music]